Set across more than four breathtaking acres and comprised of two exceptional parcels, this extraordinary compound offers a once-in-a-lifetime chance to own a true piece of East Hampton Village history. Nestled along the tranquil shores of Hook Pond, with over 260 feet of linear water frontage, the property enjoys sweeping southern vistas of the Atlantic Ocean and the iconic Maidstone Golf Course. Just moments from the charming shops and dining of East Hampton's Main Street and the pristine Atlantic beaches, this estate marries natural beauty with prime location. The compound offers exceptional potential for generational living, with substantial buildability on both parcels. At 36 Jeffreys Lane, there's the opportunity to create a substantial estate, with allowances for up to 12,000 square feet of gross floor area above ground. This could include a grand main residence, a legal guest cottage, a swimming pool, and even a tennis court-an ideal canvas for creating a private resort-style retreat. Next door, 24 Jeffreys Lane offers room for up to 7,000 square feet above ground, making it perfect for a secondary residence or guest accommodations. This property carries a rich story of its own: Originally built in 1815, the historic home once stood on Main Street, just south of The Circle. It remained in the Dayton family until 1923, when Mary Talmage, recognizing its charm and significance, carefully relocated it to the serene and leafy Jeffreys Lane-an enclave that continues to exude the timeless allure of East Hampton. Together, these two parcels present a rare blend of historic character, scenic beauty, and future potential-ready to be transformed into a legacy estate for generations to come.